Beste daktassen-logo

Daktas versus dakkoffer

Have you ever had to transport many items or accommodate a big family in your vehicle, only to find yourself lacking space for storage? It’s a common issue, but luckily, there are solutions! The market offers some of the best roof storage systems, such as roof boxes and roof bags. But with so many options available, it’s easy to feel overwhelmed. That’s why we’re here to help! In this article, we’ll break down the key differences between roof boxes and roof bags, so you can decide based on your unique needs. From budget to durability to suitability, we’ve got you covered. Our goal is to make it easier for you to choose between a roof bag and a roof box, depending on what works best for you.

Roof Bag vs Roof Box ? Head-to-Head Comparison

In order to make an informed decision between a roof bag and a roof box, it is important to conduct a head-to-head comparison of the two options. This will allow you to evaluate the pros and cons of each choice and determine which one would best suit your needs. Both a roof bag and a roof box offer additional storage space for your vehicle, but there are significant differences between the two. By analyzing these differences, you can confidently select the option that is most compatible with your specific requirements.

Vehicle Roof Cargo Bags

Many vehicle owners have discovered the usefulness of roof cargo bags for transporting their belongings. These bags can provide up to 18 cubic feet of storage capacity comparable to dakkoffers. One of the most significant advantages of roof bags is their ease of use, as they can be effortlessly packed and stored after use. They can be neatly folded into small blocks and placed in a box or a small space within your vehicle. Additionally, roof bags are easy to mount to your car without the need for a roof rack.

One of the great things about roof bags is that they are made of flexible tarpaulin materials, which enables them to accommodate oddly-shaped items that cannot fit in traditional roof cargo boxes. Moreover, they are budget-friendly, making them a practical choice for those who want to save money. The design of roof bags has evolved over time, resulting in models that feature ergonomic features, anti-weather properties, and enhanced security features due to their location on the vehicle roof. If you need a reliable and efficient way to transport your belongings, roof cargo bags are an excellent choice.

Vehicle Roof Cargo Boxes

A roof box is a great option if you’re looking for a secure and reliable way to transport your belongings. Unlike roof cargo bags, which can be flexible and less secure, roof boxes are rigid and non-flexible, ensuring that your items are safely stored during transport. Many dakkoffers come equipped with secure locks, providing added peace of mind for vehicle owners who want to keep their valuables safe and secure.

One of the key advantages of using a roof box is its increased security level. Many are made with hard and durable shell casings, which help to protect your belongings from potential damage or theft. Additionally, the rigid construction of roof boxes ensures that your items remain secure and stable during transport, even when driving at high speeds or navigating rough terrain.

Another benefit of using a roof box is its added storage space. With a roof box, you can easily increase your vehicle’s cargo capacity, transporting more items without sacrificing interior space. This makes it a great option for families or groups of travelers who need to transport bulky items like luggage, camping gear, or sports equipment.

In addition to the added storage space, a roof box also offers protection from the elements. Rain, snow, wind, and other weather conditions can often damage or ruin items that are stored in the open air. With a roof box, your belongings are shielded from the elements, ensuring that they remain dry and secure during transport.

Overall, a roof box is a smart investment for anyone who needs to transport items regularly. With its durable construction, secure locking system, and added storage capacity, it offers a level of convenience and peace of mind that is hard to beat. So if you’re looking for a safe and reliable way to transport your belongings, consider investing in a roof box today.

Roof Box vs Roof Bag ? Difference Between Roof Box and Roof Bag

When comparing a roof bag and a roof box, it becomes clear that the two products have significant differences. As a potential buyer, it’s important to have all the relevant information to make an informed decision and avoid any regrets. Here are the differences between a vehicle storage roof bag and a storage roof box:

De noodzaak van een imperiaal voor een voertuig

If you need more storage space for your vehicle, roof bags and roof boxes are both great options. However, it’s essential to understand the differences between the two. Roof bags are a convenient option that does not require a roof rack. They can be easily attached to your vehicle’s roof without the need for additional equipment. On the other hand, roof boxes require a roof rack for mounting. These are popular because they can significantly increase your vehicle’s storage capacity. However, it’s essential to note that not all roof boxes are compatible with all roof racks. Before making a purchase, it’s important to check for compatibility to ensure your roof box works with your vehicle’s roof rack. By doing so, you can maximize the storage potential of your vehicle while keeping your belongings safe and secure during your travels.


When considering storage options, it’s logical to assume that roof bags and roof boxes offer similar capacities. However, it’s important to note that roof bags only provide up to 18 cubic feet of space, while roof boxes offer nearly 22 cubic feet more. If you require additional space, selecting a roof box is the better choice. They provide more space and come in a range of sizes, allowing you to choose from multiple options offered by various manufacturers.


When it comes to safeguarding your belongings while traveling, opting for a roof box over a roof bag can offer added peace of mind. This is because roof boxes are typically designed with a rigid structure and come equipped with locking systems, making them more secure than their flexible counterparts. Additionally, the external casing of a roof box is usually made from a durable material, which further enhances its ability to protect your valuables.

In comparison, a roof bag may not offer the same level of security as a roof box. Although some roof bags have locking systems, their flexible material makes them vulnerable to potential theft. Someone could easily approach your vehicle, touch the roof bag, and determine if there are any valuable items inside. If they suspect there are, they could then use a sharp object to slit the bag open and steal the contents. This makes roof bags a less secure option for those who prioritize the safety of their belongings.

Overall, if security is a top concern when traveling with items on your vehicle’s roof, it’s best to choose a roof box over a roof bag. With their rigid structure, locking mechanisms, and durable material, roof boxes provide added protection against potential theft.

Opslag mogelijkheid

When deciding whether to purchase a roof box or roof bag, you should consider the material used for storage. Roof bags are highly versatile as they can be folded into small enclosures or shelf spaces, making them convenient. They can be stored in any shape, while roof boxes require a designated storage spot when not in use. You can keep your roof box in the garage or store it in your vehicle’s trunk if there is enough space. However, leaving it on the roof of your vehicle at all times can be problematic when traveling under low overhanging structures and bridges on the road. It’s essential to weigh the pros and cons of each option before choosing which storage solution is best for your individual needs.


When deciding between purchasing a roof box or roof bag for your vehicle, cost is an essential factor. Those with a larger budget may find roof boxes more suitable for them. However, a roof bag may be a better option if you are on a tighter budget. It’s worth noting that affordable roof boxes are available on the market, with retail prices similar to roof bags. On the other hand, expensive roof bags can cost just as much as roof boxes. Ultimately, it’s essential to weigh your requirements against the cost and decide based on your priorities.

Roof Bag vd Roof Box: The Final Verdict

There is usually a final verdict when comparing the roof bag versus a roof box for your vehicle. This final verdict is based on what you need. This means that before you can choose between a roof bag and a roof box, you will need to consider your requirements against the given factors:

  • Kosten
  • Opslagcapaciteit
  • Beveiligingsfuncties
  • Opslag wanneer niet in gebruik
  • Compatibiliteit met uw voertuig.

The Best Roof Bags on Amazon

Our team has meticulously analyzed and curated a comprehensive list of the most exceptional roof bags available on Amazon. We understand that selecting the right roof bag can be a daunting task, which is why we have taken the time to evaluate and scrutinize each product to ensure that it meets our high standards. So rest assured that our list only includes the top-performing and most reliable options, making it easier for you to make an informed decision.

Roofpax autodaktas

[amazon box=”B076C5479W” template=”horizontal”]

The Roofpax car roof bag is a top-tier rooftop cargo carrier with a spacious storage volume of over 19 cubic feet. Its waterproof construction makes it a highly versatile product suitable for military and civilian use. One of the most impressive features of this premium car top roof bag is its heavy-duty material, which ensures maximum durability and longevity. Moreover, this product is capable of fitting onto all types of vehicles, regardless of whether you choose to install the rack or not.

This bag is TSA approved for added convenience, meaning it can be used for traveling across state lines. It also comes with an integrated bottom bag padding material that creates a cushioned base, ensuring that your belongings remain safe and secure. With a spacious storage capacity of approximately 19 cubic feet, this bag provides ample space for carrying your items.

To ensure a secure lock system, this bag includes SBS double bag zippers, providing peace of mind knowing that your belongings are safe and secure. Additionally, its safety feature includes a light-reflecting logo that illuminates in the dark, ensuring maximum visibility and safety during night-time driving. This bag also comes with 10 elastic and strong Velcro, adding extra restraint to secure the strap.

Due to its versatility and durability, this bag can store and transport various home items. When packed to its maximum capacity, this bag easily expands to produce a size that is almost 20 inches in height. It also comes with dual-seam technology and a lifetime warranty covering its zippers and buckles, ensuring you get the most value for your investment.

Amazon Basics-daktas

[amazon box=”B072ZHRDMZ” template=”horizontal”]

The Amazon Basics rooftop bag is an exceptional choice for individuals seeking a reliable and efficient vehicle rooftop bag. This rooftop bag boasts a generous storage capacity of nearly 15 cubic feet, making it ideal for transporting bulky items such as luggage, camping gear, or sports equipment. The bag has sturdy 8-inch straps with buckles for easy attachment to the vehicle’s roof rack. Additionally, the bag is waterproof and fade-resistant, protecting your belongings from the elements, including rain, dust, wind, and harsh sunlight.

The bag features an oversized zipper closure equipped with premium stay-dry flaps and robust seams, providing added security and protection for your belongings. The bag can be effortlessly folded for compact and straightforward storage when not in use. Furthermore, the bag has a convenient carrying case/storage bag that enhances its storage abilities and makes it easy to transport.

For added safety and security, the rooftop bag includes eight sturdy straps that can be used to secure the bag’s contents, preventing rain from seeping through the opening. The bag is versatile and can be attached to roof rails, cargo baskets, or crossbars, making it a versatile and practical addition to any vehicle.

San Hima Car Roof Bag Cargo Carrier

[amazon box=”B08ZXQ313F” template=”horizontal”]

The San Hima roof bag is a highly versatile and reliable option for anyone needing extra storage space. Crafted from durable PVC mesh, this soft rooftop carrier boasts both flexibility and strength, as well as flame-retardant and waterproof properties. Additionally, the bag’s color fastness ensures that it will maintain its vibrant appearance even after prolonged exposure to sunlight.

Expertly constructed with welded seams and a concealed zipper, the San Hima roof bag provides reliable protection against moisture, keeping all contents safe and dry. With an impressive capacity of 15 cubic feet and the ability to expand to a height of 17 inches when fully packed, this rooftop carrier offers ample space for all your belongings.

Designed with aerodynamics in mind, the San Hima roof bag helps to reduce drag and increase the velocity of your vehicle when in motion. Whether you have a bare roof, basket, crossbars, or rails, this rooftop bag can be easily mounted to your vehicle for hassle-free transport.

When not in use, the San Hima roof bag can be quickly and easily folded up for convenient storage. And with its universal design, this rooftop carrier can be used with nearly any van, SUV, or car. So if you’re looking for a dependable, high-quality rooftop bag, look no further than the San Hima roof bag.

The Best Roof Boxes on Amazon

We have carefully examined and compiled a thorough list of the best roof boxes you can buy on Amazon. Choosing the perfect roof box can be overwhelming, so we have thoroughly assessed and inspected each product to ensure it meets our strict criteria. You can trust that our list only features the most dependable and top-performing options, making it more straightforward to make an informed choice.

Thule Motion XT XL

[amazon box=”B07FRSJQZ5″ template=”horizontal”]

If you’re looking for a vehicle roof box, look no further than the Thule Motion XT XL. This top-of-the-line box is available in four different size capacities, ranging from 16 to 22 cubic feet, with an additional 18 cubic foot option for alpine adventures. This roof box will impress, boasting superior features, user-friendliness, and quality. You’ll get a sleek and stylish addition to your vehicle with its refined finish and fit. And installation and operation are a breeze, thanks to its user-friendly design. Plus, the Thule Motion XT XL comes at a great price point for its exceptional value.

But that’s not all – this box is also incredibly secure and easy to use. Handles on either side make it easy to open and close, while the smooth-operating locks ensure that all your items stay safely stowed away. The aerodynamic design of the box’s nose reduces drag on your vehicle while in motion, making for a smoother and more efficient ride. And the base of the box is extra-solid, providing added stability and security.

One of the standout features of the Thule Motion XT XL is its generous overlap, which helps resist gaping and provides excellent resistance to wind. This unique feature you won’t find in many other roof boxes on the market. The Thule Motion XT XL is the ideal choice for anyone looking for a high-quality, user-friendly, and secure roof box for their vehicle.

De Yakima SkyBox 16 Carbonite

[amazon box=”B00JQWHZL0″ template=”horizontal”]

If you’re looking for a top-quality roof box for your vehicle, the Yakima SkyBox is an excellent option. This roof box is designed to work seamlessly with any vehicle and provides convenient access from either side. The Yakima SkyBox boasts a sleek, versatile design that’s hard to match. Moreover, this roof box is built to last and is surprisingly affordable.

One of the standout features of the Yakima SkyBox is its user-friendly mounting hardware. It also has a reliable lock system and a Slide lock handle that’s easy to use. You can choose between the 18 cubic feet or 16 cubic feet models, which offer ample storage space for all your gear. The Yakima SkyBox is perfect for storing all types of equipment, and it can be easily installed on your vehicle’s roof without any tools.

With a low profile design and a narrow 12-inch width, the SkyBox provides plenty of room for your bikes, boats, and other gear. This roof box has been rigorously tested to withstand the toughest road conditions and is engineered with aerodynamic shapes and rugged ABS plastic features to minimize wind resistance and road noise.

SportRack Vista XL

[amazon box=”B00BCLL8C0″ template=”horizontal”]

This particular roof box is undoubtedly among the finest budget-friendly options that can be easily found in the market. What sets this model apart is its accessibility, as it boasts an access rear opening that ensures users can easily reach all of their items without any hassle. Furthermore, you get a low-priced option that provides the convenience of a straightforward installation process coupled with ample loading capacity. The beauty of this product is that it can also accommodate your skiing equipment and other personal belongings that you must bring.

This roof box has been designed to be a fully assembled option and can be mounted on your roof rack without requiring extra mounting tools. With a massive capacity of about 18 cubic feet, you get a roof box that offers significantly more space for storing your items. This storage size is not commonly found in other models, making it an ideal choice for those who need extra cargo space. Moreover, the SportRack Vista XL has been ergonomically shaped to promote its aerodynamic features, making it an excellent option for minimizing air resistance during vehicle movements.

When it comes to the material of this box, you get a product that is not only durable but also highly functional, ensuring longevity and serviceability. Additionally, this roof box comes at a price that offers more value for each buck, as it requires little or no maintenance. It also comes with little attachments that facilitate easy installation and mounting onto the vehicle’s roof racks.

The SportRack Vista XL has an easily accommodating interior, allowing you to store all your items in the bag easily. It features security locks to help users properly secure all contents from theft. Furthermore, the external case of the rigid box works well to hold appropriately in all weather conditions. This means that regardless of any extreme weather of sun, rain, snow, and windy conditions, the box stays intact, protecting all the items placed in it. Overall, the SportRack Vista XL is a top-notch roof box that ticks all the right boxes, making it an excellent choice for anyone needing an affordable, functional, and reliable roof box.

6 gedachten over “Roof Bag vs Roof Box”

  1. Pingback: Volkswagen Passat Dakkoffer - Beste Daktassen

  2. Pingback: Koopgids Volvo XC60 Dakkoffer 2022 - Beste Daktassen

  3. Pingback: Toyota Sienna Roof Cargo Box Buyers Guide 2022 - Beste daktassen

  4. Pingback: Beste waterdichte daktassen? Best beoordeeld 2022

  5. Pingback: Should You Buy or Rent a Roof Box? - Best Roof Bags

  6. Pingback: The Best Guide to Thule Roof Boxes 2022 - Best Roof Bags

Laat een reactie achter

Het e-mailadres wordt niet gepubliceerd. Vereiste velden zijn gemarkeerd met *

vijf × 3 =