Best Roof Bags Logo

Should You Buy or Rent a Roof Box?

Should You Buy or Rent a Roof Box? 2022 Best Buyer's Guide


Should You Buy or Rent a Roof Box? 2022 Best Buyer’s Guide

Should you buy or rent a roof box? You might be wondering if renting or owning is the best option, given how much they can cost. Let’s analyze the advantages and disadvantages of owning versus renting to help you make a decision.

On the off chance that you’re on a tight budget and have a trip planned, renting a rooftop carrier rather than buying one may be a great choice. Is this, be that as it may, the foremost productive course of activity? Is it superior to lease or claim a roof box?

The response will, of course, be dependent on a number of circumstances, thus it is recommended that you consider the following criteria while making your selection.

Which things to look for before buying or renting a roof box?


The primary thing you ought to consider is that “Do you’ve got sufficient capacity space?”. A hard-shell box is a large, hefty item that will take up a lot of room. When you’re not using the box, think about where you’ll store it. If you just have a little amount of storage space, renting is the clear winner because you simply return it at the end of your rental time.

You may always go with a soft cargo bag, which will take up much less space while not in use. It’d too be less likely to require complex mounting frameworks or roof racks.

You ought to moreover think around what you’re getting to do with it whereas it’s not in utilize. Since having a cargo carrier on the beat of your vehicle will decrease your gas mileage and increment the cost of filling up your tank, most individuals expel them when they aren’t in utilize. But what do you are doing when you’ve removed the carrier?

If you select a delicate carrier made of polyester or plastic, it’ll nearly certainly come with a capacity sack merely may utilize to keep everything organized. Hard-shell carriers, on the other hand, are a small more troublesome to utilize since you’ll require some place to hang them when it’s not on your vehicle.

In the majority of situations, users erect racks on the walls of their garages or sheds to hang the carriers.

It makes no difference whether you lease or purchase a soft freight carrier. If you don’t want to deal with the inconveniences of finding a storage space for your hard-shell carrier, though, you should simply lease it. 

This way, you’ll never have to worry about correctly storing your carrier, which is especially crucial if you just have a small amount of space in your home, outside shed, or garage.


The other thing to consider is the number of trips that you often take per day. The number of ventures you take is the primary thing to consider in case you select to lease or purchase a roof box.

If you travel frequently during the year, it may be more cost-effective to purchase a rooftop carrier rather than lease one. Rooftop carriers varies in price from approximately $50 to several hundred dollars, but when you consider that a three-day rental for an average-sized cartop carrier might cost around the same amount, owning your cargo carrier may end up being less expensive in the long term.

Of course, if you’re solely concerned with cost, you should do your homework and obtain accurate figures for leasing versus acquiring your rooftop carrier. The carrier’s measure capacity, the strategy utilized to connect it to your vehicle, and the materials it’s made of ought to all be considered. 

On the off chance that you merely travel once or twice a year, renting may be the finest arrangement for you. Something else, obtaining the carrier is most likely your best choice.

Way to Attach Carrier with Roof Box

It’s moreover worth considering how the carrier is joined to the vehicle. Numerous carriers require a roof rack, whereas others basically snare the carrier to the beat of your car with a rope or strap.

If the cargo carrier you’ve fallen in adore with requires a forever joined roof rack and you’re not inquisitive about installing one on your vehicle, you will want to consider leasing one instep. That way, you won’t got to make any changeless changes to your vehicle.

You’ll be able purchase or rent the carrier on the off chance that you as of now have a roof rack or are arranged to introduce one. Other criteria can be considered in this case before coming to the last choice. 

Be beyond any doubt that you simply ought to continuously confirm with the producer of the carrier to see on the off chance that a roof rack is required. This way, you’ll know precisely what you’re getting and there won’t be any shocks once you get the carrier in your hands.

Naturally, there are cargo carriers that don’t require a roof rack; on the off chance that this can be the case, you’ll be able to either rent or buy the cargo carrier you crave. Companies who rent this item regularly utilize carriers that do not require a roof rack, so you’ll have a part of choices in the event that you would like to rent one for your roof rack-free vehicle.


Cost is another important factor in case to buy or rent a roof box. The initial cost of acquiring a roof cargo box will be far more than the cost of renting one. Unless you are just interested in the smallest and most basic devices, renting is the most cost-effective option.

The cost of hiring a roof top cargo box will most likely be between $100 and $150. You should rent a week’s worth of equipment with the required mountings for this. It could also entail the installation of the box on your vehicle.

This compares to \$500-\$1000+ for a great quality roof box and the essential mounting equipment.

Amount of Stuff

Another question that comes to mind is the amount of stuff that you have to carry. Roof boxes are typically used to transport big yet light objects. Tents, sleeping bags, pillows, and other similar items are available. You don’t want to be carrying extremely large goods onto your vehicle’s roof. 

Consider what kind of gear you’ll need and whether a roof box will suffice. Keep in mind that every vehicle’s roof storage capacity is limited, and this includes the weight of any bars, racks, or boxes.

Extra-large freight carriers might be costly, although leasing them isn’t always prohibitively expensive. Delicate pack carriers that oblige 20 to 30 cubic feet of materials are most common, whereas there are moreover hard-shell carriers that can hold a parcel of stuff as well. In the event that you wish an expansive cargo carrier and just arrange to utilize it sometimes a year, it’s likely more astute to purchase one instead of rent one.

A nice expansive carrier is exorbitant, but it can ordinarily be obtained for less than $100, while you will be investing near to this much to lease one. When leasing a cargo carrier, you’ll pay more for the bigger and better-made ones, so in case you wish a huge measure, it’s regularly superior to fair purchase one.

q? encoding=UTF8&ASIN=B01N7SXOAI&Format= SL160 &ID=AsinImage&MarketPlace=US&ServiceVersion=20070822&WS=1&tag=roofbags 20&language=en USThule Motion XT Rooftop Cargo Box
q? encoding=UTF8&ASIN=B07FRHVJYX&Format= SL250 &ID=AsinImage&MarketPlace=US&ServiceVersion=20070822&WS=1&tag=roofbags 20&language=en USThule Force XT Rooftop Cargo Box
q? encoding=UTF8&ASIN=B0171APZYM&Format= SL250 &ID=AsinImage&MarketPlace=US&ServiceVersion=20070822&WS=1&tag=roofbags 20&language=en USYakima Showcase Rooftop Cargo Box
q? encoding=UTF8&ASIN=B009NN46GE&Format= SL250 &ID=AsinImage&MarketPlace=US&ServiceVersion=20070822&WS=1&tag=roofbags 20&language=en USThule Pulse Cargo Box
q? encoding=UTF8&ASIN=B007WR25GG&Format= SL250 &ID=AsinImage&MarketPlace=US&ServiceVersion=20070822&WS=1&tag=roofbags 20&language=en USRightline Gear Sport 2 Car Top Carrier








18 cu ft

16 cu ft

15 cu ft

11 cu ft

15 cu ft


‎46 lbs

41 lbs

60 lbs

30 lbs

3.8 lbs


L: 79" W: 31.5" H: 15"

L: 74.75" W: 33" H: 18"

L: 11.81" W: 11.81" H: 47.24"

L: 88.5" W: 25.5" H: 12.5"

L: 5.31" W: 11.18" H: 12.6"


Thule Motion XT Rooftop Cargo Carrier

Thule Force XT Rooftop Cargo Box

Yakima Showcase Rooftop Cargo Box

Thule Pulse Cargo Box

Rightline Gear Sport 2 Car Top Carrier

Best Roof Boxes in 2022

Thule Motion XT Rooftop Cargo Carrier

q? encoding=UTF8&ASIN=B01N7SXOAI&Format= SL160 &ID=AsinImage&MarketPlace=US&ServiceVersion=20070822&WS=1&tag=roofbags 20&language=en USDiscover a sleek and roomy roof-mounted cargo system that’s designed for simplicity of usage. These roof boxes will assist ease outdoor outings and travels around town, with models designed to add 16-22 cubic feet of additional packing capacity.

This automobile roof top carrier is exceptionally simple to use thanks to the quick attach method and dual-side opening for quick access. The Thule Motion XT cargo box can handle everything from camping gear to luggage and everything in between. 78.7 x 31.4 x 14.9 inches on the inside.


  • Designed for best space economy, aerodynamics, and vehicle fit, the roof-mounted cargo box provides 18 cubic feet of additional packing capacity.
  • When the roof box is securely and properly placed, the quick-mount system “clicks.”
  • Quick access from both sides of the automobile thanks to the dual-side opening.
  • With grip-friendly handles and lid-lifters, it’s simple to open and close.
  • No roof box contact and full trunk access
  • The lid automatically locks in place and signals that the container is securely closed (One Key System compatible)

Thule Force XT Rooftop Cargo Box

q? encoding=UTF8&ASIN=B07FRHVJYX&Format= SL250 &ID=AsinImage&MarketPlace=US&ServiceVersion=20070822&WS=1&tag=roofbags 20&language=en USIt’s not always simple to find the ideal rooftop cargo box. There are numerous possibilities available, and many of them will appear to be strikingly identical.

In any case, this does not run the show out the plausibility of a few items standing out. You’ve likely listened to the Thule brand on the off chance that you’re recognizable with housetop cargo bins.

Thule makes a wide run of cargo boxes and other items. The Thule Drive XT Cargo Box is no exemption. They’ve made a few of the most excellent cargo boxes on the showcase.

Today you will have the opportunity to review all of the pertinent information regarding this product in order to determine whether it is worth your time. After you’ve gathered all of the information, you’ll be able to determine whether or not this cargo box is a good fit for your vehicle.

This cargo box’s overall storage capacity is likewise quite outstanding. This cargo box is habitually utilized to transport camping adapt, sports hardware, and gear. Depending on the estimate, it may hold up to eight sets of skis or six snowboards. It’s or maybe expansive and will make transporting your assets much easier.

There are bigger cargo boxes on the advertisement, but for the foremost portion, this one will suffice. It has a lot of storage space and will be ideal for hauling a variety of items. If you require even more capacity, you will almost certainly have to spend a lot more money. This cargo box is sensibly estimated and gives a significant sum of capacity, making it an amazing choice for most people.


  • A flexible roof-mounted cargo box for regular use
  • Provides 16 cubic feet of extra pressing space
  • Designed to fit a wide extend a vehicles with most extreme space efficiency
  • Quick-mount framework “clicks” when roof box is secure and legitimately mounted
  • Dual-side opening for simple get to all zones of the box, from either side of the vehicle
  • Full trunk get to with no roof box contact

• Fits 5-7 sets of skis / 3-5 snowboards (up to 175 cm)

Yakima Showcase Rooftop Cargo Box

q? encoding=UTF8&ASIN=B0171APZYM&Format= SL250 &ID=AsinImage&MarketPlace=US&ServiceVersion=20070822&WS=1&tag=roofbags 20&language=en USThis roof box is unique in that it was created with internal stiffeners to ensure that the lid not only opens and closes effortlessly, but also does not flex or break during movement.

Enjoy the convenience of opening the roof box on either side, allowing you to conveniently retrieve the items you’ve stowed without having to walk around your vehicle. While this roof box is designed for larger vehicles, it can also be readily attached to your BMW’s roof rack.

Whereas a few roof boxes are troublesome to introduce on your claim due to their estimate and weight, this one is light sufficient that one individual can do it effortlessly.

Moreover, due to the shape and development of the box, as well as how well it closes and seals tight, there isn’t much concern almost water getting interior the box accidentally. There’s no shrieking or rattling when legitimately mounted to the vehicle.


  • Internal lid stiffeners are included for durability and ease of opening and closing. Round, aerodynamic, factory, and square crossbars are all compatible.
  • Metal clamp with molded soft surface provides excellent roof clearance.
  • Easy access on both sides of your vehicle thanks to the dual-sided aperture.
  • The ultimate in hatch clearance is provided by forward-facing hardware and a truncated tail end.
  • Larger cars, wagons, and SUVs are ideal candidates.

Thule Pulse Cargo Box

q? encoding=UTF8&ASIN=B009NN46GE&Format= SL250 &ID=AsinImage&MarketPlace=US&ServiceVersion=20070822&WS=1&tag=roofbags 20&language=en USThis is one of the best roof boxes for BMW 3 Series on this list since it is extremely sturdy and rugged. When you’re ready to go on a journey, simply attach the mounting assembly to your automobile and attach the box.

The box’s secure lock ensures that it is always securely closed and won’t pop open, and because it opens on the side rather than the front, you can easily access items that you had packed for your trip.

You won’t have to worry about your roof box failing or being harmed when you are on the road because of its innovative design and the fact that it is constructed of thermoplastic material.

The lid can withstand extreme weather without being damaged or allowing water into the box, and many people choose to leave the box on the car all year for ease of use because of its shape and durability.


  • 11 cubic feet of additional packing space is provided via a functional rooftop cargo box.
  • The rugged and robust design protects the contents.
  • The FastGrip quick-mount system takes only a few minutes to put together.
  • Easy loading and unloading from the passenger side.
  • The central locking system ensures optimal security.
  • Thule Convenience Only when all locking points are securely closed can the key be removed.

4-6 skis/3-4 snowboards can be accommodated.

Rightline Gear Sport 2 Car Top Carrier

q? encoding=UTF8&ASIN=B007WR25GG&Format= SL250 &ID=AsinImage&MarketPlace=US&ServiceVersion=20070822&WS=1&tag=roofbags 20&language=en USEven if you don’t have a roof rack, this is a wonderful roof box since it has been particularly aerodynamically built to cut through the wind and air when you’re driving without you recognizing you’re travelling slower or getting worse gas mileage.

Not only can you mount this roof box to the door frame using a roof rack or auto clips, but you’ll never have to worry about anything you put in the box getting wet.

Nothing in the box will be at risk of getting wet thanks to a waterproof system that includes twin seam technology and a urethane-coated zipper that keeps water out.

Furthermore, because the roof box does not require attachment to a roof rack, mounting it on your car for a trip is quick and simple, and you won’t have to worry about planning ahead for your trip.


  • Welded seams and a waterproof zipper from SZIP; no zipper flap necessary.
  • Use the Car Clips to secure the carrier’s straps to a vehicle’s roof rack or the carrier’s straps to the vehicle’s door frame weather molding.
  • Storage capacity: 15 cubic feet; dimensions: 42″ L x 34″ W x 18″ H; intended for SUVs, minivans, and crossovers. The enclosed front end helps you fit your belongings into the carrier’s dimensions and prevents overfilling.
  • Everything you need to load it up, attach it, and hit the road in minutes is included in your luggage. Carrier, (4) attachment straps, (4) Car Clips, and stuff sack with sewn-in set-up guide are all included.

5 thoughts on “Should You Buy or Rent a Roof Box?”

  1. Pingback: Subaru Outback Roof Cargo Box Guide 2022 - Best Roof Bags

  2. Pingback: Roof Cargo Box Storage – Best buyers guide for 2022

  3. Pingback: Volvo XC60 Roof Box Buyers Guide 2022 - Best Roof Bags

  4. Pingback: The Best Guide to Thule Roof Boxes 2022 - Best Roof Bags

  5. Pingback: What Is A Roof Box – Beginner's Guide 2022 - Best Roof Bags

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

9 − one =